Hadiths about hadith criticism
34 narrations about hadith criticism from 5 collections, with translation and explanation.
The first 8 hadiths
Muslim corrects a narrator’s attribution and affiliation. Sahih — highest level of authenticity: Sahih Muslim records this narration as authentic. The passage also includes Imam Muslim’s correction of the freedman’s attribution:…
Omar upheld a divorced woman’s right to housing and maintenance. Sahih — authentic: Sahih Muslim included this narration, and its stated grade is sahih. The text recounts Omar’s appeal to the Qur’an and Sunnah in the disagreement…
Abu Dawud reports criticism of the chains of two related narrations. Sahih — highest level of authenticity: The stated grade of this narration is Sahih. The text also includes a critical assessment by Yahya ibn Sa‘id al-Qattan of…
The Prophet ﷺ sometimes slept while in a state of janabah without using water first. Sahih — authentically transmitted: The stated grade is sahih. Abu Dawud also records a criticism by Yazid ibn Harun, who considered the…
Istihādah did not prevent Umm Ḥabībah from marital relations. Sahih — authentic: The report has been graded Sahih. Abū Dāwūd also notes differing assessments of the narrator Muʿallā ibn Manṣūr: Yaḥyā ibn Maʿīn considered him…
Abu Dawud considers the abbreviated wording about raising the hands only once unauthentic. Sahih — stated grade: The grade stated in the source is sahih. Abu Dawud himself, however, adds an important qualification: in his view,…
“then listen silently” is not well preserved: in this version, it is transmitted only through Sulaiman al-Taymi. This critical remark calls for distinguishing the grading of the narration from the reliability of this particular…
Abu Dawud attributes the statement about tamattu to Ibn Abbas, not to the Prophet ﷺ. Sahih — according to the stated grading: The stated grade is Sahih. However, Abu Dawud makes an important qualification: he calls its…
All 34 hadiths about hadith criticism
In the app, you can search all hadiths by topic or keyword in your language and save the ones that resonate with you.