What if you are unsure how long you must fulfill a vow?
Al-Khudayr’s answer specifically addresses uncertainty about whether a vow entailed an ongoing obligation.
When I was young, after reaching puberty but with little religious knowledge, I made vows. Now I am unsure whether I intended to repeat the acts for the rest of my life. Must I continue doing so?
Short Answer
According to Sheikh ʿAbd al-Karim , in the case of uncertainty described, you do not have to assume an ongoing obligation. His answer is that performing the promised act once is sufficient in this situation. The uncertainty here concerns the duration: was continual repetition part of the vow? This is not a general permission to abandon vows. The sheikh instead stresses that a vow that has been made must be fulfilled.
Identify what you are uncertain about
The questioner remembers making vows. The uncertain point is whether the promised acts had to be performed repeatedly, throughout their entire life. Al-Khudayr focuses his answer on this specific point: when there is doubt about that ongoing obligation, it is not assumed.
Keep reading with Complete
You're reading a preview. The full knowledge base is part of Khutba World Complete, cancel any month.
More biographies
Questions & Answers
All questions and answers in one place: read, understand, and apply them.